Three Flavours of the Internet
The Three
Internets – That was the intriguing title of Pranay Kotasthane’s post. The first is the one people like me started with,
what Kotasthane calls “the Western one”. Accessed via the desktop or laptop.
Search engine driven. Possible to find assorted articles, even very old ones.
E-mail based.
~~
The second
one is what Kotasthane calls the “Chinese one”, superbly described by Yiqin Fu. No, Fu is not talking of the censorship
aspect aka the Great Firewall of China. So what did he mean? China was poor
when the Internet got started in the 90’s and continued to be not-so-well-off
in the 2000-10 decade. Hence most Chinese could not afford desktops or
laptops. Therefore, most of China got onto the Internet only with the advent of
the cheaper smartphones (same as most Indians). In turn, that meant the way
these folks accessed the Net was via the smartphone apps, not the
browser.
This has had
massive implications on how the Internet is used and how it is experienced!
This sounds surprising at first, so Fu elaborates. The smartphone experience,
almost always via apps, is mostly (1) quick takes and reactions
(tweets, instant messages etc); (2) commercial (online shopping,
food orders, cab bookings etc) and (3) timepass activities
(watching videos and infinite scrolls).
Now let us go into
how all of the above translates into a parallel universe of the Internet from
the first one described earlier. Very little of the smartphone-based usage (and
thus experience) is about knowledge or reflections, which would happen via blogs
or longer articles. It also meant that most of the content of the
smartphone-based Internet is short-term (who really cares of a tweet or message
from 3 years back?) as opposed to the first type of Internet, which included
the likes of blog posts, Wikipedia articles and news site articles. The data
and information of most smartphone apps is “private”, i.e., not
accessible from outside the app (e.g. what you do on WhatsApp or PhonePe). In
turn, that meant whatever is done via an app is not accessible or
searchable via the likes of Google (or Baidu, the Chinese equivalent). An
example helps. Say, you found an interesting post by someone. Well, the app
can’t help you find more of his posts, unless he is on that app and
posts his articles via that app. Do you see the contrast with the first
Internet where you’d fire a Google search to find articles, books and videos by
that person?
Emails is another
artifact, that is almost unheard of and thus unused in the smartphone-based
Internet. People text each other, they don’t email each other. On the first
Internet, email was the primary basis of online communication.
~~
The third
type of Internet is the “Indian one”, which Kotasthane describes as:
“The
elites see an internet that’s a mix of the Western one and the Chinese one
minus the censorship, while the non-elites are experiencing something much
closer to the Chinese one.”
~~
I found this
perspective fascinating. But both Fu and Kotasthane go beyond and wonder of the
implications of this. Kotasthane summarized the questions to ponder over when
he wrote:
“Forget geopolitics for a moment. And consider the impact of these three internet prototypes on their respective users. Will their cognitive effects be different? If yes, in what way?”
Comments
Post a Comment