Mathematical Thinking in Life
Jordan
Ellenberg’s book, How
not to be Wrong, is (partially) a mathematician’s answer to
the question kids ask, “What is the point of learning all this maths? When will
it ever be applied in my life? Esp. if I don’t go into a maths-y career?”
If learnt in
spirit (rather than just formulae and theorems), he says, maths instils the
quality of asking deep questions relevant to a lot of things in life:
“What assumptions are you making? And are they justified?”
~~
A few examples on
the usefulness in checking one’s assumptions follow.
The basic
principles of statistics apply to so many areas. Check the validity of
your assumptions that (1) the sample size is adequate, (2) and it is
representative. This would explain why so many polls are wrong (apart from
people lying). Or why statements by a tourist about an entire country may not
be right.
A common tendency
is to extrapolate in a linear (straight line) manner – if something is good
(bad), more of it must be better (worse). This is why many people cite the
great social welfare schemes of Scandinavian countries and argue for higher
taxes. But is the assumption of causation between higher taxes and
better social welfare valid? Even if there was a causation, is the assumption
that the connection is linear (more taxes equals more welfare) correct? Or is
there an inflection point above which too much taxation drives the cream away
and/or leads to the rise of ever-increasing ways to evade taxes?
“Not
all curves are linear… Nonlinear thinking means the way you should go
depends on where you already are.”
Talking in percentages
is very helpful – it makes comparisons easy. But beware if the data has
negative numbers (e.g. loss). In that case, percentages should not be
used. Why not? An example makes it obvious: say A makes a profit of ₹60, B a profit of ₹80, and C a loss of
₹40. The total adds to ₹100 (since C was lossy and thus negative). That means
A’s share would 60% and B’s share would be 80%. See the problem? The two add up
to more than 100%!
Correlation means two things are connected e.g. as the economy does better, so too does the stock market. But correlation is not transitive. What does that mean in simple English? Let’s say you find A and B are correlated. And also that B and C are correlated. But, the two findings don’t mean that A and C are also correlated. A silly example makes it clear – the father is a blood relative of his son; the son is a blood relative of his mother; and yet this doesn’t mean that the father and mother are also blood relatives…
Comments
Post a Comment