Contested Indian History #6: Sow the Wind...
As mentioned
earlier, the Nehruvian reasons for wanting history schoolbooks common across
the country was to focus on commonalities across regions and religions, even if
that meant ignoring obvious differences and conflicts, says Shaan Kashyap in Who Owns History?
Later day seasoned
politicians like Indira and the Janata Dal had an idea of where to draw the
line. Then came Rajiv Gandhi. With no experience and a massive majority, he
could do anything. While he did nothing dictatorial, he would sow the seeds of
deep discord, first by overturning the Shah Bano verdict (gender issue for
Muslim women v/s Sharia law). And then by banning The Satanic Verses by
Salman Rushdie. Both issues had a historical component to them (what did
Islamic texts say? Should a secular, modern country continue those?), and
historians didn’t exactly cover themselves in glory in either issue. The
intelligentsia continued on their trajectory of communal harmony trumping
everything else, saying that while they supported free speech and gender
equality, it could not be at the cost of affecting communal harmony.
Well before the
pendulum had swung as far out as it did from 2014 onwards (Modi era), the
Ayodhya and Mathura movements showed signs of where things could be headed. At
this point, historians like Romila Thapar found their voice, challenging the
historical accuracy of the claims in both places.
The point Kashyap is making is not the historical correctness (or lack of it) in these instances. Rather, he is drawing attention to the fact that historians, who had been silent on all other topics until then, were beginning to speak up as the BJP/ RSS/ VHP’s Kamandal politics began to rise. Such selective voices would lead to the eventual backlash against both establishment historians (and historians in general) and the intelligentsia, albeit it would take a long while (Modi wave) before it could attain critical mass.
Comments
Post a Comment