Posts

Contested Indian History #7: Ayodhya

Once the Ayodhya/Babri Masjid topic entered the courts, the historians drew a “clear and unwavering line between historical evidence and the reasons of faith”. They went about the topic as if it consisted of 3 questions. (1) Is present day Ayodhya the same one as the one in the Ramayana ? (2) Was Ayodhya a holy site only for Hindus? Or was it like Jerusalem, a holy site for multiple religions? (3) Was the Babri Masjid built on the same site where a temple had existed?   Note how the 3 questions are all factual. Historians went about it as if they could “pass informed judgment on the past, and in doing so, help steer present-day controversies”, writes Shaan Kashyap in Who Owns History?   If that was how historians perceived their role (at that point), then one can understand (which is not the same as agreeing) the backlash of the 2014 Modi era against historians. In case you didn’t get it, here is the summary – If religion and faith should have no say in the Ayodhya ...

Three Flavours of the Internet

The Three Internets – That was the intriguing title of Pranay Kotasthane’s post . The first is the one people like me started with, what Kotasthane calls “the Western one”. Accessed via the desktop or laptop. Search engine driven. Possible to find assorted articles, even very old ones. E-mail based. ~~   The second one is what Kotasthane calls the “Chinese one”, superbly described by Yiqin Fu. No, Fu is not talking of the censorship aspect aka the Great Firewall of China. So what did he mean? China was poor when the Internet got started in the 90’s and continued to be not-so-well-off in the 2000-10 decade. Hence most Chinese could not afford desktops or laptops. Therefore, most of China got onto the Internet only with the advent of the cheaper smartphones (same as most Indians). In turn, that meant the way these folks accessed the Net was via the smartphone apps, not the browser.   This has had massive implications on how the Internet is used and how it is exp...

Contested Indian History #6: Sow the Wind...

As mentioned earlier, the Nehruvian reasons for wanting history schoolbooks common across the country was to focus on commonalities across regions and religions, even if that meant ignoring obvious differences and conflicts, says Shaan Kashyap in Who Owns History?   Later day seasoned politicians like Indira and the Janata Dal had an idea of where to draw the line. Then came Rajiv Gandhi. With no experience and a massive majority, he could do anything. While he did nothing dictatorial, he would sow the seeds of deep discord, first by overturning the Shah Bano verdict (gender issue for Muslim women v/s Sharia law). And then by banning The Satanic Verses by Salman Rushdie. Both issues had a historical component to them (what did Islamic texts say? Should a secular, modern country continue those?), and historians didn’t exactly cover themselves in glory in either issue. The intelligentsia continued on their trajectory of communal harmony trumping everything else, saying that whil...

Mathematical Thinking in Life

Jordan Ellenberg’s book, How not to be Wrong , is (partially) a mathematician’s answer to the question kids ask, “What is the point of learning all this maths? When will it ever be applied in my life? Esp. if I don’t go into a maths-y career?”   If learnt in spirit (rather than just formulae and theorems), he says, maths instils the quality of asking deep questions relevant to a lot of things in life: “What assumptions are you making? And are they justified?” ~~   A few examples on the usefulness in checking one’s assumptions follow.   The basic principles of statistics apply to so many areas. Check the validity of your assumptions that (1) the sample size is adequate, (2) and it is representative. This would explain why so many polls are wrong (apart from people lying). Or why statements by a tourist about an entire country may not be right.   A common tendency is to extrapolate in a linear (straight line) manner – if something is good (bad), mo...

Contested Indian History #5: "Secular History"

In the early 1960’s, the topic of national integration became the paramount concern of Nehru as communal riots, language-based secessionist movements, and regional demands exploded. To that end (national integration), terms like “religion”, “caste” and “language” became sociopolitical categories with specific definitions (set by the Center) and mandatory for states to follow, writes Shaan Kashyap in Who Owns History? “Schools as an institution and school textbooks as site of knowledge were given the responsibility to fabricate national integration.”   History books had to serve an agenda (national integration). To give credibility to the books, respected historians of the day were called to help write history textbooks for schools. Many historians squirmed at factual accuracy being demoted to a secondary role. But other historians agreed – some because they agreed with the positive motive behind the ask, others opportunistically to gain brownie points with those in power. His...

No AIDS via Mosquitoes

I ran into yet another question which made me wonder why it (the question, not the answer) hadn’t even occurred to me. As icing on the cake, the answer turned out to be even more fascinating.   The question? If sharing a needle can spread AIDS, why can’t a mosquito spread it too? They look like “tiny flying syringes”, they pierce the skin, they draw blood, they bite multiple people. Those details are relevant to malaria, why not AIDS?   Now for the answer. A syringe is a single tube. Blood goes in, blood comes out. A mosquito’s proboscis, on the other hand, has two tubes. One sucks blood out. The other injects saliva into you (to prevent the blood from clotting). “You’re not getting the last person’s blood. You’re getting mosquito spit.” HIV, the virus that causes AIDS, does not live in spit. Thankfully.   In addition, a syringe or a razor blade doesn’t digest anything. It is a neutral surface on which the HIV virus can stay peacefully. A mosquito’s stoma...

Contested Indian History #4: State Controversies

Education was a state subject at independence. The first controversy based on a state history textbook was in 1957 when the CPI formed the government in Kerala. Via the Election Bill, Kerala restricted the hitherto unlimited powers enjoyed by private management in the field of education, and conversely, gave the state government far greater power in setting textbooks, writes Shaan Kashyap in Who Owns History?   Large pictures of Karl Marx, Lenin and Mao adorned Class 8 textbooks.   The Russian Revolution was glorified. China, the books said, would race ahead of India because they were communist. The achievements of non-communist countries were ignored. Not surprisingly, a huge uproar followed, both within Kerala and from sections of the Center. Accusations of “communist history” and “ideological indoctrination” to brainwash the next generation flew around. “They have a found in the nationalization of textbooks a fertile ground for indoctrination.”   The Directo...