Contested Indian History #7: Ayodhya
Once the Ayodhya/Babri Masjid topic entered the courts, the historians drew a “clear and unwavering line between historical evidence and the reasons of faith”. They went about the topic as if it consisted of 3 questions. (1) Is present day Ayodhya the same one as the one in the Ramayana ? (2) Was Ayodhya a holy site only for Hindus? Or was it like Jerusalem, a holy site for multiple religions? (3) Was the Babri Masjid built on the same site where a temple had existed? Note how the 3 questions are all factual. Historians went about it as if they could “pass informed judgment on the past, and in doing so, help steer present-day controversies”, writes Shaan Kashyap in Who Owns History? If that was how historians perceived their role (at that point), then one can understand (which is not the same as agreeing) the backlash of the 2014 Modi era against historians. In case you didn’t get it, here is the summary – If religion and faith should have no say in the Ayodhya ...